Start with the accounting you need
Pilot publishes bookkeeping, tax, and CFO offerings. Institution provides managed accounting alongside tax coordination, compliance, company records, and other finance services. Compare a written assignment rather than assuming either service catalog represents one standard package.
List entities, source accounts, billing, payroll, reporting basis, and delivery needs. Explain whether the books are current. Pilot's entry cash-basis plan should not be treated as the price of every accrual requirement; ask both providers which scope produces the schedules and review you need.
Service models at a glance
| Provider | Published service model | Scope to confirm |
|---|---|---|
| Institution | Finance operations and managed accounting | Bookkeeping, tax coordination, compliance, and finance services |
| Pilot | Packaged bookkeeping with separate finance services | Bookkeeping, tax, and CFO offerings |
References: Institution: published services; Pilot: published services
Check the handoffs between service lines
Use a customer prepayment, processor refund, or payroll correction to test the proposed workflow. Ask what evidence is needed, who prepares the accounting, and who reviews exceptions. A software connection does not establish that the resulting balance has been reconciled.
For tax preparation, request the filing list, responsible professional, review, and approval process. For CFO work, define the model, meeting cadence, assumptions, and maintenance. A shared provider name should not replace those assignments.
Compare the complete cost and software arrangement
Request setup, cleanup, recurring accounting, tax, finance projects, and software charges separately. Check billing timing, volume limits, and how additional work is authorized. Use the current official pricing pages and a proposal for your actual scope rather than an older quoted figure.
Institution's Dashboard access is separate from paid accounting services. Connected accounting requires QuickBooks Online and its separately billed Intuit subscription. Confirm the software and access terms of the Pilot proposal as well, including any migration or historical-data requirements.
Use the first close as the acceptance check
Request an anonymized close package and trace a material balance to support. Agree the reporting deadline, required client inputs, correction process, and backup contact. If planning is included, check that it uses approved actuals and visible assumptions.
Retain company access, usable exports, reconciliations, schedules, and unresolved items. Choose the proposal that covers your present reporting needs and makes any later scope change explicit, with the professional boundaries and work retained internally documented.
Sources
Requirements and product details can change. Check the linked guidance for the facts that apply to your situation.
Related reading
Need help with this work?
General information, not personalized accounting, tax, legal, or investment advice. Have the appropriate qualified professional review decisions that depend on your circumstances.