Start with the scope page
Most proposals put the price on the first page and the scope on the last. Read the scope first. It tells you what the monthly number actually buys.
Look for named deliverables: a profit and loss statement, a balance sheet, a cash flow statement, and the accounts that will be reconciled. Then look at timing, such as final statements by the tenth business day. If the proposal says only that the firm will provide accounting support, ask it to be specific.
Lines to find in every proposal
A complete proposal answers each of these. If one is missing, assume it is not included until it is in writing.
- The accounting method: cash or accrual.
- The accounts and payment sources that are reconciled each month.
- Who prepares and who reviews.
- What is included for payroll, sales tax, and contractor reporting.
- Whether the tax return and extension are included or priced separately.
- Cleanup of earlier months: included, priced separately, or excluded.
- Onboarding or setup fees, and software costs.
- Hourly rates for work outside the plan.
- The term, the renewal, and the notice you must give to leave.
What changes the price mid-year
Look for clauses that let the provider raise the fee. Common ones are a volume cap on transactions or monthly spending, a charge per additional entity or state, and a charge for late or incomplete documents. These are fair if they are clear. Ask for the thresholds in numbers, so you know where the next price tier starts.
Compare in a grid
When you have two or three proposals, build a grid with the jobs on the left and the providers across the top. Mark each cell included, add-on, you keep it, or not offered. Add the add-ons you expect to use, then compare the totals.
The proposal that leaves the fewest important jobs unclear is usually the better choice, even when its number is not the lowest.
Ending the engagement
Check how you get your records back. You should be able to export your accounting file, receive a closed trial balance at the cutoff date, and get reconciliations and supporting schedules. A provider that makes this difficult has told you something about how it works.
Frequently asked questions
What is the most common surprise in a proposal?
Cleanup and the tax return being priced separately from the monthly fee.
How long is a typical engagement?
Many are month to month or annual. Check the notice period and whether the price can change at renewal.
Can I take my records with me?
You should be able to export your accounting file and get the closing trial balance and reconciliations. Confirm it in the agreement.
Sources
Requirements and product details can change. Check the linked guidance for the facts that apply to your situation.
Related reading
Need help with this work?
General information, not personalized accounting, tax, legal, or investment advice. Have the appropriate qualified professional review decisions that depend on your circumstances.