Compare control responsibilities, not only bookkeeping
AccountingDepartment.com publishes outsourced bookkeeping and controller services. Institution provides managed accounting with other finance operations and tax-coordination services. The decision should reflect the level of accounting ownership and review your company requires.
An organization with an internal finance lead may want an external accounting team under that person's direction. A founder-led company may also need a reviewer to identify policy questions and explain the reports. Put that difference into the brief for each provider.
Service models at a glance
| Provider | Published service model | Scope to confirm |
|---|---|---|
| Institution | Finance operations and managed accounting | Bookkeeping, tax coordination, compliance, and finance services |
| AccountingDepartment.com | Outsourced bookkeeping and controller team | Bookkeeping and controller services |
References: Institution: published services; AccountingDepartment.com: published services
Look for supported balance-sheet accounts
Request an anonymized close package with reconciliations for material accounts. Trace a loan balance, customer deposit, prepaid expense, or payroll liability to its support. Ask who prepares the schedule and who approves adjustments.
Controller review should be described as observable work. Determine which accounts are reviewed, how unusual entries are escalated, and how unresolved matters affect final reporting. The title controller alone does not establish the frequency or depth of review.
Protect approvals and company access
Agree the permissions for vendor creation, bank-detail changes, bill approval, payment release, and journals. Where the provider executes a transaction, identify the management approval required and the evidence retained.
Ask how access is granted to named staff and removed when roles change. Confirm which ledger and supporting records the company can export. Provider-managed administration should not leave you uncertain about the practical steps needed for a future transition.
Scope work outside the close
List tax preparation, payroll processing, collections, forecasting, entity compliance, and assurance separately. Institution's adjacent services may help when those jobs need coordination, but confirm the professional and contractual boundaries. Request an equally explicit list from AccountingDepartment.com.
Compare first-year and ongoing fees after matching account coverage, activity, reporting basis, review, and deadlines. Use the first close to check whether the delivered schedules and explanations match the proposal. Keep corrections and open questions in a record that both management and the accounting team can follow.
Sources
Requirements and product details can change. Check the linked guidance for the facts that apply to your situation.
Related reading
Need help with this work?
General information, not personalized accounting, tax, legal, or investment advice. Have the appropriate qualified professional review decisions that depend on your circumstances.